Amicus Attorney by CARET vs. 8am™ MyCase

Overview
ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price
Amicus Attorney by CARET
Score 9.9 out of 10
N/A
Amicus Attorney is a legal practice management platform which focuses on growth and business development, from AbacusNext in San Diego.
$49
Per User Per Month
8am™ MyCase
Score 8.2 out of 10
N/A
8am MyCase provides web-based practice management software designed for solo and small firm legal professionals. MyCase aims to offer a secure, all-in-one legal practice management solution to alleviate the burden of high caseloads, poor client communication, and practice management operations. The product aims to help users spend less time managing their firm and more time practicing law. MyCase can be accessed from any device or computer so users can manage documents and…
$49
per month per user
Pricing
Amicus Attorney by CARET8am™ MyCase
Editions & Modules
Amicus Cloud
$49.00
Per User Per Month
Basic
$49
per month per user
Pro
$99
per month per user
Advanced
$119
per month per user
Offerings
Pricing Offerings
Amicus Attorney by CARET8am™ MyCase
Free Trial
NoYes
Free/Freemium Version
NoNo
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
NoNo
Entry-level Setup FeeNo setup feeNo setup fee
Additional DetailsDiscount available for annual billing.
More Pricing Information
Community Pulse
Amicus Attorney by CARET8am™ MyCase
Considered Both Products
Amicus Attorney by CARET
Chose Amicus Attorney by CARET
In the time that I have been with my firm, we have not used any other comparable software. As a result I can't compare it to anything else that is out there.
Chose Amicus Attorney by CARET
Amicus Attorney has been a solid competitor for at least a decade. LexisNexis does not seem to invest a lot of time into new features for Time Matters, but the same can be said for Amicus Attorney in recent years. ProLaw is in a category of it's own (especially in regards to …
Chose Amicus Attorney by CARET
Actionstep is a true cloud-based Practice Management system. Actionstep is superior to Amicus in every aspect, more customizable, more fully featured and better sales/support resources. It is unfortunate what has happened to Amicus, which appears to be based on someone's greed …
8am™ MyCase
Chose 8am™ MyCase
8am MyCase stands head and shoulders above PracticePanther and probably on par with Tabs3. At the time we used Tabs3, it did not have a client portal feature and was just beginning to venture into the cloud. As such, while it had many good features, its cost and lack of …
Chose 8am™ MyCase
LawPay is how I started my journey. It has been an excellent payment processor for my practice. CosmoLex is the platform I used previously - it just wasn't as robust as MyCase. I've worked in Clio environments with co-counsel on several projects. I think MyCase to Clio is a …
Chose 8am™ MyCase
Carpe Diem was used at larger firms and it may have been the settings, but it was much harder to use.

Clio was fine, but I love the partnership that MyCase has with LawPay
Chose 8am™ MyCase
MyCase helps alongside the other products that we use.
Chose 8am™ MyCase
MyCase has higher processing fees. I would not have selected MyCase had I known about the hidden fees.
Chose 8am™ MyCase
Prior to using MyCase, my firm relied on AbacusLaw for its CRM program. I have also used Amicus Attorney prior to that. AbacusLaw and Amicus Attorney were local area network programs using an onsite computer server. I started using MyCase so that I would have an entire …
Chose 8am™ MyCase
Clio was really hard to set up (even adding clients) back in 2013. It was also way more expensive than MyCase. I've also looked into Lawcus, Practice Panther, and a few others. I decided to stay with MyCase because they add new features all the time, and it's a local company.
Chose 8am™ MyCase
I prefer MyCase over the alternative practice management services out there simply because it's easy to use and straightforward. The user interface is clean and intuitive. Practice Panther comes close in that regard but still feels clunky and out dated. It makes me feel like …
User Ratings
Amicus Attorney by CARET8am™ MyCase
Likelihood to Recommend
7.0
(0 ratings)
8.0
(0 ratings)
Likelihood to Renew
-
(0 ratings)
8.0
(0 ratings)
Usability
-
(0 ratings)
9.0
(0 ratings)
Support Rating
-
(0 ratings)
7.0
(0 ratings)
Implementation Rating
-
(0 ratings)
10.0
(0 ratings)
Configurability
-
(0 ratings)
1.0
(0 ratings)
Vendor post-sale
-
(0 ratings)
10.0
(0 ratings)
Vendor pre-sale
-
(0 ratings)
10.0
(0 ratings)
User Testimonials
Amicus Attorney by CARET8am™ MyCase
Likelihood to Recommend
Small to medium-sized law firms can greatly benefit from Amicus Attorney. It provides a central repository for all case management as well as calendaring between employees and their assistants. Document automation can also greatly save employee time (requires additional configuration and setup).
Read full review
It is great for taking credit card payments, managing calendars, sharing and accepting document uploads and maintaining digital files. The app is better than nothing, however is vastly inferior to the web version. The time entries should show on the first screen whether they are marked as billable or non-billable without having to enter each specific time entry
Read full review
Pros
  • It is very helpful with tracking our time and allows us to start a timer when working on a project to keep an accurate log.
  • Since it is web-based, it can be used to log into email and contacts remotely, which I have found extremely helpful on several occasions.
  • The phone messages are also very helpful. Amicus will populate the caller information with the caller's contact info (if stored on our system) and generates an automatic email to the individual for whom the call was intended.
Read full review
  • Securely transfer documents to and from clients and opposing counsel
  • text messaging with clients and other contacts
  • Managing our office calendar with color coding for different office personnel
  • Taking and adding our credit card payments
  • Maintaing our digital files in the cloud allowing us to access them from anywhere at anytime
Read full review
Cons
  • Subscription based only, formerly allowed "ownership" of software with annual maintenance agreement. Software has moved to a monthly subscription where one "leases" the software from the owner, Abacus.
  • Software stability, can occasionally have server-level issues that require cycling of services in order to restore connectivity.
  • Exchange calendar sync does not warn users that sync is not occurring. After updating Active Directory password, password needs updated in Amicus Attorney. Problem being, it does not remind / alert if the synchronization is not occurring.
Read full review
  • Time Entries should show as billable and non-billable without the need to open each time entry to see if it is billable or not
  • The app should allow searching for text messages just as the web version does
  • The app should allow searching for files just as the web version does
Read full review
Likelihood to Renew
No answers on this topic
I don't personally handle whether or not we renew our subscriptions to platforms but it's very integral to our work so I doubt we'd get rid of it
Read full review
Usability
No answers on this topic
It is so easy to use. We've had multiple people join our team and they don't have any issues using it right away. It's also easy to use new features as they're developed. I think everyone should have and use a simple case management platform, and MyCase is my usual recommendation.
Read full review
Support Rating
No answers on this topic
Years ago, they were very supportive. They tend to address issues, but they aren't very communicative when dealing with feedback. They just add new features suddenly. There aren't many issues with our platform, so we don't have many questions now, but years ago, we did have some issues that needed to be addressed and then they were much more responsive.
Read full review
Online Training
No answers on this topic
We love the program.
Read full review
Implementation Rating
No answers on this topic
None. This thing is a no brainer for a small law firm.
Read full review
Alternatives Considered
In the time that I have been with my firm, we have not used any other comparable software. As a result I can't compare it to anything else that is out there
Read full review
Prior to using MyCase, my firm relied on AbacusLaw for its CRM program. I have also used Amicus Attorney prior to that. AbacusLaw and Amicus Attorney were local area network programs using an onsite computer server. I started using MyCase so that I would have an entire cloud-based legal CRM program. At the time its best competitive feature was that the program was entirely cloud-based and that online retrieval of documents and client contact information was easily retrievable. The best contribution of these features is not just improving team collaboration, but improving efficient communication with clients by allowing them online access to their case file and secure communication with the client portal. Our Intake staff uses Clio Grow as a CMS (Contact Management System) despite some intake features being added my MyCase in the past year. Clio Grow has a Kanban board interface to manage incoming leads and improve intake team collaboration. MyCase's intake feature is new and less robust and intuitive to use compared to Clio Grow (formerly Lexicata). From the beginning, G Suite has always been an integral tool for email and calendar management. MyCase offers email and calendar support but G Suite is easiest to use on multiple platforms and hardware devices compared to MyCase.
Read full review
Return on Investment
  • In years past, Amicus was a great product with very good support
  • The positive impact we get now is revenue from moving our clients to other platforms (away from Amicus)
Read full review
  • Organization: I know where to go for my case details
  • Efficiency: I just leave a window open on one screen logged into mycase and I can instantly modify/update matter details
  • Billing: integrated credit card payments/invoice updating is nice. Invoicing is a lot easier than prior platforms I used given you can email the invoice out directly from the platform, and see when it has been viewed.
Read full review
ScreenShots

8am™ MyCase Screenshots

Screenshot of the main dashboardScreenshot of a case overviewScreenshot of trust accountingScreenshot of the billing dashboardScreenshot of time and expense reporting