CDW vs. OneSource Virtual

Overview
ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price
CDW
Score 3.0 out of 10
N/A
CDW is a large, global value-added reseller and service provider, providing technology and services to business, government, education and healthcare organizations in the United States, Canada and the United Kingdom. CDW is a public, Fortune 500 company.N/A
OneSource Virtual
Score 5.1 out of 10
N/A
OneSource Virtual is a provider of Workday services, solutions, and products for over 850 customers around the world. Payroll, finance, benefits, and HR solutions, purpose-built for Workday technology and specially designed to give customers access to deeper data insights.N/A
Pricing
CDWOneSource Virtual
Editions & Modules
No answers on this topic
No answers on this topic
Offerings
Pricing Offerings
CDWOneSource Virtual
Free Trial
NoNo
Free/Freemium Version
NoNo
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
NoNo
Entry-level Setup FeeOptionalNo setup fee
Additional Details
More Pricing Information
Community Pulse
CDWOneSource Virtual
Considered Both Products
CDW
Chose CDW
CDW is a top-tier partner with most reputable tech companies. This aids in getting the best prices available.
Chose CDW
They are more competitive at some solutions while also lacking in others. Primarily when going against products that solely focus on one area.
Chose CDW
Office Depot and SHI do have great representatives but have found CDW to be very encompassing as far as Information Technology is concerned.
Chose CDW
CDW is still easier to work with than SHI. While CDW has its issues, at least they make an effort to communicate. It has been difficult to even get basic communications out of SHI.
Chose CDW
I would recommend CDW to all customers over their competition.
Chose CDW
CDW is able to offer a 'one-stop shop', for all your needs in your IT organization. This makes it very simple to pick up the phone and call just one person, to get something ordered or a request to meet a vendor initiated. It also makes it very simple to call one person, when …
OneSource Virtual
Chose OneSource Virtual
OSV is more flexible, more human.
Chose OneSource Virtual
When we implemented in 2013, we evaluated several payroll partners. Due to proximity and the services they presented, they quickly floated to the top of the list.
Chose OneSource Virtual
I used Workday project services for my first deployment of Workday and OneSource Virtual was much more supportive and consultative during deployment.
Chose OneSource Virtual
I used ADP for a short time while we implemented Workday (payroll), and I can say it was not so user-friendly. Once we transitioned to Workday and brought [OneSource Virtual] onboard, life became much easier.
Chose OneSource Virtual
I like that OneSource Virtual has access to our database and can help us however it is needed. [Whereas] other companies we looked at do not touch our system.
Chose OneSource Virtual
ADP was a full service (which I think OneSource Virtual also has) but we don't use it. we just have them complete the backend work after payroll is complete.
Chose OneSource Virtual
I was not involved in the selection of [OneSource Virtual]. I do know other Companies are better at communication and response time.
Chose OneSource Virtual
I have not used or evaluated any other services like OneSource Virtual.
Chose OneSource Virtual
The support provided by [OneSource Virtual] has been superior to that of ADP. In addition, the partnership with Workday as their payroll and HR platform is superior to that of ADP.
Chose OneSource Virtual
We feel that we receive a much better "bang for our buck" with OneSource Virtual. They provide flexibility that we do not believe we would receive from the other vendor.
Chose OneSource Virtual
We used another vendor previously for the same exact services and moved to OneSource Virtual due to ongoing service issues. I was unable to get problems answered in a timely manner and there was no escalation path. I no longer have that issue. OneSource Virtual's solution …
Chose OneSource Virtual
The level of support and flexibility of OneSource Virtual is far superior to my experience with ADP. They are readily available to assist with troubleshooting as well as day-to-day needs. ADP was difficult to get in touch with and had a box product that required our business …
Chose OneSource Virtual
We have not utilized other partners in our Workday journey.
Chose OneSource Virtual
We were with an older version of ADP that was about to be discontinued. Our big struggle, quite frankly, was that we felt like a very small fish in a large pond. The customer service component was not to our satisfaction. We reviewed 18 different vendors prior to making a …
Chose OneSource Virtual
When we were evaluating OneSource Virtual for Tax processing we also reviewed our options with ADP. We made the decision to go with OneSource Virtual because they offer the flexibility to be able to support our overall Workday payroll processes (and honestly the entire system) …
Chose OneSource Virtual
We have not used another consulting firm for Workday support. We now use Workday Success Plans.
Chose OneSource Virtual
Prior to our implementation of Workday and use of OneSource Virtual, our fulfillment provider was using a very outdated system that could not handle complex things. We had a hard time with any projects, especially ones that required quick turnaround, and often had to customize …
Chose OneSource Virtual
We have only used or considered OneSource Virtual in the due diligence process for implementing Workday.
Chose OneSource Virtual
We evaluated 1 other implementation partner, but there wasn't any comparison. OneSource Virtual made us very comfortable from the beginning, allowing us to interview members of their project team. They were also helpful in providing recommendations for other outside …
Chose OneSource Virtual
Without disclosing the other vendors we shopped out, OneSource Virtual was right in the middle of the pack for cost. What gave them the project was that they had a long history of success with implementations, as well as a large percent of all Workday implementations. Our HR …
Chose OneSource Virtual
We did not use OneSource Virtual to help us implement Workday. We used a competitor that did a fine job, but we quickly moved to OneSource Virtual post-implementation to take our tenant to the next level!
Best Alternatives
CDWOneSource Virtual
Small Businesses

No answers on this topic

No answers on this topic

Medium-sized Companies
AVI-SPL
AVI-SPL
Score 8.6 out of 10

No answers on this topic

Enterprises
AVI-SPL
AVI-SPL
Score 8.6 out of 10

No answers on this topic

All AlternativesView all alternativesView all alternatives
User Ratings
CDWOneSource Virtual
Likelihood to Recommend
7.4
(0 ratings)
7.9
(0 ratings)
Likelihood to Renew
-
(0 ratings)
9.2
(0 ratings)
Usability
-
(0 ratings)
9.1
(0 ratings)
Support Rating
-
(0 ratings)
7.5
(0 ratings)
Implementation Rating
-
(0 ratings)
9.1
(0 ratings)
User Testimonials
CDWOneSource Virtual
Likelihood to Recommend
CDW is a good place to go for a large selection of competitively-priced goods to purchase directly from their web store, but customer service is still lacking, even after all these years; look at various review sites online. Management appears to still be out of touch, or possibly as high as the executive level?
If CDW doesn't value our business (and we're an SMB, so not a big juicy account that they're sure to court but we do conduct tens of thousands of $ per year range), there are several alternatives. I need to be convinced otherwise as most account reps themselves are great, but that's the end of the line on customer service for u.
Read full review
OSV uses tickets/cases for communication, which makes it easy to open and monitor the status of transactions. They are great at net pay processing and filing taxes. If things are not moving along, you can reach out to your Tax Specialist or Customer Success Manager, and they can help escalate concerns. It sounds like they are rearranging their tax filing department so they can facilitate quicker resolutions, so I hope that benefits their customers. They are also interested in reaching out and making things right for the customer. Their Knowledge Center online could use a re-vamp. The search function is not useful at all, and I have a difficult time finding forms such as ACH Reversal form, or the Stop Payment form.
Read full review
Pros
  • Website is very convenient and easily navigated.
  • Quotes are always competitive.
  • The range of products and services that they provide is outstanding.
Read full review
  • Payroll Processing - we never have late payments.
  • Education - I can ask a question like, "why did this pull into retro" and I will get a quick and accurate response.
  • Always improving - OneSource Virtual is always improving processes and the teams are getting better at what they do.
  • Garnishments - a garnishment team is a well-oiled machine, they know their role and do it well.
Read full review
Cons
  • High staff turnover.
  • Small organizations are treated as second-class citizens.
  • Seems to have an agenda based on what their vendors are offering them for incentives.
Read full review
  • We receive far too many emails from our cases. They send three just to start with.
  • Better knowledge of the tax deferrals due to Covid19.
  • A better reminder of when your contract will end. They spring it on you at the very last second and then you cannot look outside of OneSource Virtual because you need coverage.
Read full review
Likelihood to Renew
No answers on this topic
I do feel they are a great extension to the payroll service
Read full review
Usability
No answers on this topic
Have had no issues with getting what we need from this service
Read full review
Support Rating
No answers on this topic
Overall, we receive great customer support from OneSource Virtual. The only real hiccup we have had has been around taxes and response times. We had a longer than expected lag in cases regarding notifications from the IRS-which are very important and have to be answered timely. We were able to resolve with SDM but didn't feel that we should have had to escalate.
Read full review
Implementation Rating
No answers on this topic
I would say the benefit we had was that we engaged OSV as our Workday implementation partner, therefore, the rest was seamless.
Read full review
Alternatives Considered
CDW is able to offer a 'one-stop shop', for all your needs in your IT organization. This makes it very simple to pick up the phone and call just one person, to get something ordered or a request to meet a vendor initiated. It also makes it very simple to call one person, when something goes wrong and get assistance.
Read full review
The level of support and flexibility of OneSource Virtual is far superior to my experience with ADP. They are readily available to assist with troubleshooting as well as day-to-day needs. ADP was difficult to get in touch with and had a box product that required our business to conform to instead of being able to flex to meet business needs. OneSource Virtual has a deeper platform than Paychex, however, the level of customer support is equal.
Read full review
Return on Investment
No answers on this topic
  • [OneSource Virtual] saves me time by preparing all of our tax filings [so that] I can focus on more of the review and analysis of our payroll costs
  • Once I run the payroll complete process, [OneSource Virtual] takes over the settlement process giving me one less thing to worry about
  • [OneSource Virtual] has allowed us to keep our overhead costs low, allowing the company to use those savings on other initiatives while the company grows
Read full review
ScreenShots