Google Cloud Key Management vs. HashiCorp Vault

Use for most types of cloud SQL services. Excellent modern-day encryption technologies. If a customer wants to manage their keys then Google Cloud Platform is well suited for those people if it matters. Able to divide workloads and pipelines. Customer managed encryption keys support for Data fusion, Data Proc, Cloud SQL, and GKE. We use Cloud EKM: key use operations $0.03 per 10,000 operations for our day to day operations.

Incentivized

Vault is a reliable and resilient as the Key Management System. It is not for the novice user that does not have a background in information security. It requires a significant time investment into the different key engines that the solution offers to get started. It works very well once implemented and is very flexible in general.

Incentivized

• Option for Customer-Managed Encryption keys for Cloud which very [few] providers do.
• Option to enhance security via Hardware Security Modules.
• Easy control panel and CLI.
• Unified commands to approve or deny key requests.

Incentivized

• The HTTP API you use to write and read secrets is open and can be used by any application.
• It keeps our sensitive data/credentials out of our GitLab repositories.
• Sealing and unsealing the Vault on demand adds an additional layer of security.

Incentivized

• They removed the option for RSA128 bit security so yeah if it matters it a bummer.
• Pipelines are limited and very [few] for the amount you pay.
• General usability and Rapid CI/CD.

Incentivized

• Documentation for the API moves slower than changes in the API itself
• The database secret engine's API design isn't as elegant as it could be
• No support for revocation of all secrets under one path

Incentivized

HashiCorp Vault is the best there is out there, and it has become critical to our secret management use cases. It would be difficult to find anything that would suit our needs better and that would be beneficial for us to switch over to.

Incentivized

We spent a little more time than we imagined to conceptually understand how HashiCorp Vault operates, as well as how it is configured. This is not trivial, and keep in mind that you will need to take some time to get a thorough understanding of the tool. The documentation could be more helpful in this regard.

Incentivized

Hashicorp has been very responsive to our questions and inquiries up to this point. We are currently working on them to develop a more granular permissions model within Vault. We are very close to achieving our objectives with the help of their support team. We do not seem to be in the same time zone which makes it hard for escalated issues.

Incentivized

The UI / UX, first of all, is night and day difference. The main attraction after the services were this: It's user friendly. It welcomes new users and properly guides them on what to do and what you can expect. Honestly, I had a very bad experience with Microsoft Azure in 2018, so I think the Google Cloud Key Management service is best for me for now and I may give the new Azure a try later.

Incentivized

HashiCorp Vault integrates with a lot of tools and systems, and the documentation was pretty robust with a lot of community help. Because HashiCorp Vault is also older than other solutions, it is already well developed with a lot of features you need for storing secrets and configuration. HashiCorp Vault is also friendlier towards application build and is focused in providing security and a lot of customization for almost any use case scenario. Bitwarden is more limited to password management of enterprise accounts, but for application usage is not that great or easy to integrate. It does not scale well also. AWS Secrets Manager on the other hand is really good but more limited to AWS applications and vendor lock is problematic as well for such a critical piece of infrastructure.

• There is no Return of investment in our operations as we use it for KMS.
• The only ROI is that we have a piece of mind while our data is handled by Google.
• Our main objective is being fulfilled and the staff as well as customer are happy.
• Value for money.

Incentivized

• Allowed better access control for credentials, passwords, and important keys.
• After we started using HashiCorp Vault, we were able to base our environment 100% as code.
• SSH access control that is possible using HashiCorp Vault adds an extra level of security in environments where external remote access is required.

Incentivized