GTreasury vs. Kyriba

Overview
ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price
GTreasury
Score 8.4 out of 10
N/A
GTreasury offers their treasury management system for funds and transfer management, liquidity tracking, customizable accounting rules with ERP integration, and other liquidity management features.N/A
Kyriba
Score 9.8 out of 10
Enterprise companies (1,001+ employees)
Kyriba empowers CFOs, Treasurers and their IT counterparts to transform liquidity as a dynamic, real-time vehicle for growth and value creation. Kyriba is a secure, scalable SaaS platform that leverages artificial intelligence, automates payments workflows, and enables thousands of multinational corporations and banks to maximize growth, protect against loss from fraud and financial risk and reduce operational costs. Kyriba states that for…N/A
Pricing
GTreasuryKyriba
Editions & Modules
No answers on this topic
No answers on this topic
Offerings
Pricing Offerings
GTreasuryKyriba
Free Trial
NoNo
Free/Freemium Version
NoNo
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
NoNo
Entry-level Setup FeeNo setup feeNo setup fee
Additional Details
More Pricing Information
Community Pulse
GTreasuryKyriba
Features
GTreasuryKyriba
Treasury Management
Comparison of Treasury Management features of Product A and Product B
GTreasury
-
Ratings
Kyriba
7.4
Ratings
2% below category average
Cash and Liquidity Management00 Ratings8.80 Ratings
Financial Fraud Prevention00 Ratings6.40 Ratings
Treasury Management Payments00 Ratings7.90 Ratings
Bank Account Management00 Ratings7.00 Ratings
Treasury Risk Management00 Ratings6.40 Ratings
Treasury Reporting00 Ratings7.50 Ratings
Liquidity Forecasting00 Ratings8.20 Ratings
Market Data00 Ratings7.00 Ratings
User Ratings
GTreasuryKyriba
Likelihood to Recommend
8.4
(0 ratings)
9.1
(0 ratings)
Likelihood to Renew
5.7
(0 ratings)
9.3
(0 ratings)
Usability
8.0
(0 ratings)
8.0
(0 ratings)
Support Rating
3.0
(0 ratings)
10.0
(0 ratings)
Implementation Rating
1.0
(0 ratings)
8.0
(0 ratings)
User Testimonials
GTreasuryKyriba
Likelihood to Recommend
It is well-suited for providing information about what cash is available and its future outlook of it. It helped us to link the multiple bank accounts that we have globally into one consolidated location. We were then able to ensure that we had the cash required to meet the various business needs that we have.
Read full review
This tool is a great solution and in spite of all the flaws, it has been rendering its services for the longest time. The platform is user-friendly and it just completely empowers your organization with a whole view over all types of cash positions that automatically provides an organization with the liberty to make a correct decision at any point in time. From my experience, I must say that this product has been delivering a highly secure enterprise platform.
Read full review
Pros
  • Reporting automates bank balance view(s) by sending daily email recipients.
  • [It] includes the GL account coding on the funding templates to automate the posting of JEs for that transaction.
  • [It] synergizes bank transactions via a single portal rather than multiple logins for multiple bank platforms.
Read full review
  • Keeps our very large multi-bank account structure in balance daily, and gives daily visibility to all bank account balances for Treasury and the rest of Mercy
  • GL Mapping, creation and export of GL entries, and reconciliation of ALL GL entries back to the bank accounts.
  • Listens to client's suggestions and ideas, responds quickly with answers, regularly updates software based on our input. Also, they have a great Kyriba Social website where we can put in tickets for help and send in our ideas, but more importantly, share questions and ideas with the whole Kyriba client community, and provides FAQ from that dialogue for just about any question that we can think of. Great customer support and communication works well both directions.
  • Implementation process is well mapped out, but flexible to the client's needs. If I'm experienced and comfortable with TMS systems, I can do a lot more of the setup work instead of paying Kyriba to do it all, but if I need Kyriba to do it all, they will. Love the training process, which works a lot like college, where they teach you a section, give you homework to do before the next training session, check your accuracy and understanding, and move on to the next section. Almost all the Kyriba implementation folks I've worked with and met with were former Treasury practitioners, so they know what we know and they how to talk to us and with their developers to give us what we need.
  • Very high value for the low cost and scale-able depending on how many modules you need. Monthly fees are very reasonable, implementation fees are known up front, and you only pay for what you use, and annual volume based fees are reasonable as well. Much, much cheaper than bank fees for Information reporting, didn't require any MIS approval or assistance, and very easy to justify to upper management based on the massive labor savings.
  • One of the big reasons I love Kyriba so much is TMS is all they do and they have grown consistently in the 4 years we've been with them, and are very stable. I like that their whole focus is on providing the best TMS platform on the market, and not getting off track working on other non-TMS priorities and products. In the past, many TMS systems were owned by larger conglomerates, were bought and sold multiple times, and often times support and customer service was non-existent, and coworkers were leaving the firm left and right. Many went to Kyriba. That's the main reason I started looking and found Kyriba in the first place.
Read full review
Cons
  • IHB should be created as a separate module and not be spread out across multiple functions
  • CAMT script that is currently used should be replaced by an actual plugin
  • Reporting module needs to be more user friendly and allow users to extract larger data sets
  • An ability to view a bank statement on-screen w/o extracting it into PDF would go a long way. Different from Balance Explorer.
Read full review
  • Some of the financial transaction cash flows do not integrate well with cash management and forecasting
  • Dashboards and Power BI are not readily available out of the box in the baseline product
  • Tracking of interest on bank accounts is not available in an automated fashion
Read full review
Likelihood to Renew
[I feel] it's too hard to use and navigate around [and] very difficult to manage/administer. We may keep it because [I feel] we [have] already gone through the pain point and don't want to risk going through that again. Unfortunately, if we keep it, [I believe] it's not because we love it.
Read full review
Very powerful treasury management tool, the reason it's not a 10 is implementation and support lags behind competitors. It can take a long time for issues to get resolved. But once it's set up properly, everything works well most of the time. Few if any other providers will have the same range of features.
Read full review
Usability
For me, reporting is very important and I just don't find it very user-friendly. [To me,] the location of certain functions is also confusing which I resort to using the search function. [In my case,] I have had two conversations with two different people in GTreasury and they both also agreed with me on this. They also said to just use the search function. [I believe] a lot of the reporting areas could be updated and made better. [I feel that] unless you have had a lot of training, a user would have a very hard time customizing reports. [In my experience,] even GTreasury employees agreed with me on this one.
Read full review
It can always be better. There needs to be more instances wherein the user can make changes that work for them and those changes would be saved for future use, not having to make the same changes over and over again.
Read full review
Support Rating
Day-to-day support is very quick and responsive. However, if you need to go the second level it might take longer and you lose the visibility.
Read full review
We have weekly calls with our support team to discuss ongoing implementation projects and other issues we find from time to time. They are very responsive to any questions we have and can escalate issues to a higher level of support if they do not have the expertise necessary to fix the problem. They are helpful in coordinating testing with banks if necessary, and provide regular statistics regarding support calls, causes of problems, and resolution.
Read full review
Implementation Rating
Weekly meetings and updates a plus Set realistic timeline expectations Have a good project manager Make sure everyone is following the same time line and dependencies list Keep track of a future state or out of scope list You may need to change the scope and do a project request form change, that's OK if you determine a key function has been missed Don't be afraid to extend the timeline to make sure through testing has been done prior to going live Document set up decisions, how reports and worksheets work, and why certain user codes are or are not in the positioning reports.
Read full review
We had some issues with one of the implementation people provided by Kyriba. The communication skills were lacking, with assumptions being made as to what we knew already. It was very frustrating. Once that was resolved, further module implementations have been smoother.
Read full review
Alternatives Considered
I have used Orbit and Kyriba in the past. Orbit from [a] previous company. It was fairly user-friendly even though it does not have all the bells and whistles. What I liked most about Orbit is the customer service. Everyone was very responsive. We chose GTreasury because we all agreed it appears to have everything we needed. The demos we received looked great and looked easy to use. The reporting function seemed very robust. The account manager assigned to us at the time, Jake, was great. He was very responsive and helpful. His responsiveness was also one of the reasons why we probably went with GTreasury because we felt like we had someone advocating for us.
Read full review
The above are all examples of bank rec software, Kyriba was selected over its competitors after a comprehensive vetting process. Kyriba has served us well, covering the bank rec process efficiently as well as being a one-stop-shop for treasury and banking-related functions for our group of companies.
Read full review
Return on Investment
  • Very positive ROI allowing us to take our daily cash target down to 1% of total admitted Assts. Prior to GTreasury we were running close to 20%.
  • Reduced bank service cost initially by $300,000+ and annually a minimum of $50,000.
  • Allowed us to maintain and streamline Treasury Staff FTE level, with the ability to train other areas for self service payment research, so the Treasury Analyst can focus on value added analysis tasks.
Read full review
  • Kyriba saves our department time, which is the most valuable thing we have. Before Kyriba we had to log into each bank to pull data for the prior day before we could enter our current day activity. Now the banks send the data right to Kyriba! It saves us about 3 hours of work each day from our old process.
  • Kyriba has given us visibility into all of our bank accounts in a centralized platform. We can better monitor activity and use that information to make better business decisions.
  • Kyriba has given us better transparency because of dual approval. One person has to enter information and another person has to approve information, so we have tighter controls.
Read full review
ScreenShots

Kyriba Screenshots

Screenshot of the Liquidity Analytics Dashboard in Kyriba, which offers a real-time and actionable overview of an organization's liquidity position and related metrics, helping treasury professionals make informed decisions and ensure optimal cash management strategies.Screenshot of the Cash Analytics Dashboard in Kyriba, that presents crucial financial information that enable finance teams to answer questions like, Do I have enough cash? Are my cash forecasts reliable? What is my activity with banks?Screenshot of the Payments Analytics Dashboard in Kyriba, that gives users an at-a-glance overview of their organization's payment activities, ensuring efficient payment processing, compliance with approval workflows, and effective management of financial transactions.Screenshot of the Compliance Analytics Dashboard in Kyriba, that helps users monitor and manage fraud risks, ensure compliance with regulations, and respond to potential incidents, thereby safeguarding the organization's financial integrity and reputation.Screenshot of the Risk Analytics Dashboard in Kyriba, which helps to manage financial risk by answering questions like, How much is available on my credit lines? What is my borrowing profile? What is the value of my financial assets?Screenshot of the Supply Chain Finance Analytics Dashboard in Kyriba, that helps users manage and optimize their organization's working capital position, improve the cash conversion cycle, and make informed supply chain financing decisions to achieve financial efficiency.