Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company vs. TidyCal

Overview
ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price
Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
Score 9.6 out of 10
N/A
Acuity Scheduling is an appointment management platform developed by the company of the same name in New York and acquired by Squarespace in 2019.
$14
per month
TidyCal
Score 9.8 out of 10
N/A
A tool to make scheduling the next meeting easier with calendar integrations, booking pages, and customization. Trying to schedule a meeting can lead to the hassle of back-and-forth emailing to find a time that works. (“Next month is a no-go, too. Should we try for 3 p.m. CT after the next solar eclipse?”) Also coordinating between time zones and tracking availability across personal and work calendars can be a challenge. TidyCal is presented as an…
$39
one-time fee per user
Pricing
Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace companyTidyCal
Editions & Modules
Emerging
$14
per month
Growing
$23
per month
Powerhouse
$45
per month
TidyCal
$39
one-time fee per user
TidyCal Agency Plan
$79
one-time fee per user
Offerings
Pricing Offerings
Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace companyTidyCal
Free Trial
NoNo
Free/Freemium Version
NoYes
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
NoNo
Entry-level Setup FeeNo setup feeNo setup fee
Additional Details
More Pricing Information
Community Pulse
Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace companyTidyCal
Considered Both Products
Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
I chose Acuity because I have a squarespace website and it seamlessly integrated into my website very easily.
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
We have only used acuity.
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
Acuity's user interface was much cleaner and easier to use when scheduling meetings. We love that you can embed it within your own website and it shows the calendar right there instead of redirecting you. Acuity gave us the ability to customize our meeting types and the …
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
Calendly does not play nice with my email provider. As soon as I click the accept button, the email disappears with all information--it isn't in Trash, Spam, the Inbox, or anywhere else. There isn't usually a way to automatically add the appointment to my calendar. If I am not …
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
Acuity is just way easier for me to use and has everything that I need (and their packages are very reasonably priced).
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
I chose Acuity over Calendly because of the better integrations with my tech, and the payment options.
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
One of my favourite things about Acuity, in comparison to other business tools that I use, is the minimal monthly fee. It's more than reasonable for how well it organizes and schedules my time and my business
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
Calendly and Acuity Scheduling have a similar feature set and both are user friendly. The reason I selected Acuity Scheduling, ultimately, is that it offers an always free plan that has a robust enough feature set to make the software practical and usable, whereas the free tier …
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
I prefer Acuity Scheduling to Calendly mainly for the customization capabilities. It fits many different business models. Calendly is more basic.
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
I would go with another company if you are a growing company that would surpass 36 calendars at one point. Acuity blocks scalability once you achieve some success.
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
Calendly did not allow clients to make multiple appts at once so it was too much of a hassle for clients who wanted to schedule 5 appts. I like that Acuity allows them to do it in one form.
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
I have not used any other platforms besides Acuity Scheduling for appointment generation purposes.
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
I previously used Appointmentcore (an Infusionsoft product). While it did most of what Acuity Scheduling does, I found that it was overpriced and that outside of Infusionsoft, the integrations were not as robust as Acuity Scheduling. I feel like Acuity Scheduling outperforms …
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
I liked Calendly, but Acuity seemed to be the industry leader and it works with SquareSpace, which is a huge plus. I want whatever app I use to be around for the long haul.
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
I researched several solutions and settled on Acuity and have never looked back since then.
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
I had issues with the Calendly/Zoom integration. No problems integrating Zoom and Acuity.
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
Overall, the cost, ease of use, and setup were all above average with Acuity. I tried many different programs (some not listed as a comparison) but I was very happy with Acuity and am glad we stuck with it.
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
  • Acuity Scheduling is excellent, but since Dubsado is a complete business management system, I ended up leaving Acuity Scheduling to avoid paying twice for the same type of product.
  • I'd say that Acuity Scheduling and Dubsado measure up about the same. There wasn't any specific …
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
I have not tried any other scheduling software. I was referred to Acuity Scheduling and it met my needs so I did not feel the need to look elsewhere.
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
I have not used any other products like Acuity. I did all of this on my own through my web-site at first (they would email me a request and then I would do everything manually). I did have several (up to 50) people recommend it to me!
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
I don't recall specific scheduling tools I looked at, but I looked at a few dozen. Time and time again I was unsatisfied. UIs were less intuitive. Client-based scheduling was emphasized. There were many more options than I needed. The reminder templates were poor or unable to …
Chose Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace company
We've been trying Hubspot, Calendy, and Vyte and found them a bit more complicated regarding sync and usage.
TidyCal
Chose TidyCal
In google calendar, we can't do advance booking. First, we have to collaborate on confirming a time suitable for everyone before scheduling a meeting this may lead to time waste for all the parties, this problem can be solved with the help of TidyCal resulting in better time …
Chose TidyCal
Tidycal have the 90% of the features of Calendly but for 29$ it is the best relation price-performance.
Tidycal is very simple to set up and use.Very easy integration with zoom/365/google calendar
If you need to integrate with PayPal it is easy and no extra cost (We do not use)
Chose TidyCal
TidyCal was a cleaner product and integrated well with our existing Google environment. For certain positions, IT for example, it was a clear choice and users on both ends found it good.
Chose TidyCal
I can use the free plan, which includes unlimited monthly meetings and appointments. However, I can only link one calendar. The free plan calendar supports Google Calendar and Office 365
Chose TidyCal
Because TidyCal has more features, more user friendly and no issues with integration or worries about any errors or overlaps that might occur. On top of that, knowing that more features will come into play in the future, it is truly an amazing application that helps in my line …
Chose TidyCal
I did not select TidyCal. Ultimately I selected Appointlet because I found the interface easier to work with. They also had a very generous free program and allowed you to take payments. From what I've seen it doesn't seem like you can easily take payments directly through …
Best Alternatives
Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace companyTidyCal
Small Businesses
vCita
vCita
Score 8.5 out of 10
CoSchedule Marketing Suite
CoSchedule Marketing Suite
Score 10.0 out of 10
Medium-sized Companies
LeanData
LeanData
Score 10.0 out of 10
CoSchedule Marketing Suite
CoSchedule Marketing Suite
Score 10.0 out of 10
Enterprises
Zoom Workplace
Zoom Workplace
Score 8.4 out of 10
Google Calendar
Google Calendar
Score 9.5 out of 10
All AlternativesView all alternativesView all alternatives
User Ratings
Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace companyTidyCal
Likelihood to Recommend
10.0
(0 ratings)
9.8
(0 ratings)
Likelihood to Renew
9.3
(0 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
Usability
9.5
(0 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
Support Rating
9.7
(0 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
User Testimonials
Acuity Scheduling, a Squarespace companyTidyCal
Likelihood to Recommend
I think any business can benefit from Acuity Scheduling. In my experience, however, and maybe I just haven’t found the correct settings yet, it’s been difficult to manage 4 business schedules with multiple employees and varying hours that change day-to-day and week-to-week. So I definitely would recommend it to more simple business models with set hours, as it seems like it would have all the functions one might need. I still would recommend to more complex businesses like mine as well, but also include discussion of some of the potential drawbacks.
Read full review
Maybe if you are needing a large enterprise solution you may need something else but we have found that it fits all of needs as a 32 people team. It has worked flawlessly since we installed it. I keep focusing on this but it is a 30 min set up and that’s it.
Read full review
Pros
  • Clicking on the link opens up my calendar, which has an uncluttered look, making it easy for my prospects and clients to review their options and make their choice.
  • I am able to customize my schedule, the types of appointments I want to offer, and even decide how many appointments I want in a day. There are so many details that I can customize.
  • I can customize how my calendar and emails look for my prospects and clients so that I come across professional and coordinated. I want the look of my business, website, etc. to have a polished, cohesive, and interesting presence.
  • I love that there is a workshop/class/series option for my workshops. My attendees reserve their place and pay upfront. I can duplicate these events or add future dates. It's wonderful. This saves us a lot of time and is so convenient.
  • I haven't had any trouble with my scheduler. It works flawlessly, so I don't have to take time out of my day to fix, troubleshoot or call customer service.
  • I love that I can add questions for my prospects to answer right away before booking a call. This means 3 fewer steps for me. 1. They answer these questions without an email from me. 2. They make their reservation and get a follow-up email, right away. 3. I customized the follow-up email with more details and actions to take to prepare for our call.
Read full review
  • The ability to create multiple booking types and personalize them
  • The integration of Zoom and payment types
  • The ability to create scheduling polls for group meetings
Read full review
Cons
  • There are a lot of pages for similar things so sometimes its hard to find the location of where to edit things
  • The ability to stop a review request email from being sent to specific clients.
  • A way to block of clients scheduiling 3 times when you only have 2 openings and a way to cancel that easier.
Read full review
  • There is a learning curve it takes some time for new user to understand the process.
  • UI can be made attractive.
  • Integration with other video conference tools like Amazon's chime
Read full review
Likelihood to Renew
Acuity Scheduling has been very reliable. If you don't believe me, check out their status page here. They do a pretty decent job maintaining their app. To be fair, it's a pretty simple tool so they shouldn't run into too many hiccups given it doesn't feature near as many options as other applications on the market run.
Read full review
No answers on this topic
Usability
It's just very intuitive once you get the hang of it, which won't take long. They try not to make complex things very complex and they provide explanations for everything with a greyed-out question mark icon next to the function. Also, I love that they encourage people to just get live help when they need it.
Read full review
Usability is ridiculously easy.
Read full review
Support Rating
Every time I had a question on how to do something or had any issues with Acuity Scheduling, mainly in the very beginning, when I was learning the platform, customer service was excellent. They were prompt to respond, friendly, and very helpful until I had the right solution.
Read full review
No answers on this topic
Alternatives Considered
Acuity's user interface was much cleaner and easier to use when scheduling meetings. We love that you can embed it within your own website and it shows the calendar right there instead of redirecting you. Acuity gave us the ability to customize our meeting types and the information collected from the person scheduling the meeting.
Read full review
I can use the free plan, which includes
unlimited monthly meetings and appointments. However, I can only link one
calendar. The free plan calendar supports Google Calendar and Office 365
calendar integration. The software has been tried and tested by numerous employees from different backgrounds in our organizations. The interface was a hit with the majority of them, and they found it to be incredibly useful.
Read full review
Return on Investment
  • Minimizing no shows
  • Giving me back time by taking tasks off my mind/to-do list to focus on bigger more important things
  • Payment management (it helps me make sure I receive my payments/recurring payments and follow up with clients if a payment has failed)
  • Honestly just saving me from scheduling nightmares and headaches
  • Timezones! It does it for you! (I work internationally)
Read full review
  • It cut my Scheduling time by at least 50%.
  • It impresses my clients and saves them time.
  • It's the reason some of my clients end up hiring me.
Read full review
ScreenShots

TidyCal Screenshots

Screenshot of