Lumar vs. Screaming Frog SEO Spider

Lumar

17 Reviews and Ratings

Screaming Frog SEO Spider

194 Reviews and Ratings

Overview
Product	Rating	Most Used By	Product Summary	Starting Price
Lumar	Score8 out of 10	N/A	DeepCrawl is a search engine optimization software solution offered by DeepCrawl.	N/A
Screaming Frog	Score9.9 out of 10	N/A	N/A	$149 per year

Pricing

Lumar

Screaming Frog

No answers on this topic

Paid Version: $149.00
per year

Pricing Offerings
Lumar	Screaming Frog
Free Trial
No	No
Free/Freemium Version
No	Yes
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
No	No

No setup fee

No setup fee

—

—

Community Pulse
Key User Insights
	Lumar	Screaming Frog
Considered Both Products	Lumar (formerly Deepcrawl) Billy Heany Organic Search Manager in Product Management at GroupM (Marketing & Advertising, 5001-10,000 employees) Chose Lumar Lumar is great for what it does - tracking technical changes and opportunities for a site. It does so affordably as well. In my opinion it would be best compared to Screaming Frog as it does essentially the same thing but with less flexibility on the backend and a much cleaner … Incentivized Helpful? Verified User Chose Lumar Screaming Frog is somewhat quicker, and I prefer it for issues I need to check up on immediately. But for larger analysis and full site architecture audits, DeepCrawl has a simpler interface and allows for deeper insights without needing to dig around. I appreciate all the … Incentivized Helpful? Verified User Chose Lumar I feel like they're both pretty similar from my experience, as I have always used the same things. However, I do feel that deepcrawl is easier to use from a UX perspective and I found it easier to get around to find the elements as I required them. Incentivized Helpful? Katie Goh SEM/SEO Analyst in Marketing at Healthgrades (Hospital & Health Care, 501-1000 employees) Chose Lumar Personally I prefer seoClarity's crawler and it's built into their all in one platform. Deepcrawl has a nice interface though Incentivized Helpful? Jane Phelps CEO at Know Agency (Marketing and Advertising, 11-50 employees) Chose Lumar They have a technical component to their software, but DeepCrawl is more detailed. Incentivized Helpful? James Egan Data and Insight Consultant in Marketing at Surfingturtle (Computer Software, 5001-10,000 employees) Chose Lumar All of the products I have used have been amazing in their own way, but DeepCrawl makes it easier to put it into visuals. Sometimes when you look at results, it can be quite difficult to get something easy to understand. DeepCrawl gets rid of that, the results are so easy to … Incentivized Helpful? Verified User Chose Lumar DeepCrawl is a great tool when compared to other similar solutions. What sets it apart from the competition in my experience with it, is the convenience of the cloud. In addition to having a multitude of tools faced by a digital marketer in today's landscape from analysis of … Incentivized Helpful?	Screaming Frog Chris Coultas SEO Specialist in Marketing at Evri (Package/Freight Delivery, 5001-10,000 employees) Chose Screaming Frog The biggest difference between DeepCrawl and Screaming Frog is cost. Screaming Frog is significantly cheaper, and fits within a budget much easier. For most websites that aren't huge it crawls quicker to. DeepCrawl is the better tool for analysing larger websites and is easier … Incentivized Helpful? Verified User Chose Screaming Frog Screaming Frog SEO Spider does so much...a lot of these tools, in theory, should be used together because they lend big picture insights. But Screaming Frog SEO Spider is excellent because it can work directly with tools like Google Analytics. Incentivized Helpful? Alanna Hawley SEO Strategist in Marketing at Tangible Value (Marketing & Advertising, 1-10 employees) Chose Screaming Frog The choice to go with Screaming Frog was really mostly about price and the fact that it does almost the same exact thing. There are a few things that DeepCrawl does that Screaming Frog doesn't, but it wasn't worth the increase in price. Incentivized Helpful? Scott Walker Director of Digital Marketing in Marketing at 407 Marketing (Marketing and Advertising, 1-10 employees) Chose Screaming Frog Screaming Frog has a free version, so it competes with the paid programs (like Moz) solely in the fact that it can be used without incurring a budget line item. Compared to many other programs that also offer free scans, Screaming Frog is fast and much more customizable. Since … Incentivized Helpful? Frank Watson CEO in Marketing at Kangamurra Media (Marketing & Advertising, 1-10 employees) Chose Screaming Frog A highly competent tool that leads in some areas and not in others. Incentivized Helpful? Verified User Chose Screaming Frog The HTML-heavy little platform, Screaming Frog, is my favorite crawler compared to DeepCrawl and SEMRush. Partially precisely due to the fact that the tool doesn't try to give me recommendations or tell me what to do. Many similar tools go above and beyond to prescribe … Incentivized Helpful? Verified User Chose Screaming Frog Even though Screaming Frog is the industry standard, that doesn't mean that it's without its flaws. The crawl visualization is sub-par compared to Sitebulb, and the UX/UI looks like it's from the 90s and hasn't been updated since then. Tools like DeepCrawl and Sitebulb are … Incentivized Helpful? Katie Goh SEM/SEO Analyst in Marketing at Healthgrades (Hospital & Health Care, 501-1000 employees) Chose Screaming Frog We have a deep crawl integration with another tool and still find the information on DeepCrawl valuable because this tool is better at listing out reccomendations. However, Screaming Frog is easier to use, doesn't have limits on how many crawls it can run (on the Pro plan we … Incentivized Helpful? Anthony Daronzio SEO Director in Marketing at Boomerang Pharmaceutical Communications part of Accenture (Marketing and Advertising, 201-500 employees) Chose Screaming Frog Screaming Frog is a desktop application that uses your own resources to crawl a site (Processing, RAM, Connection speed). Deep Crawl is a cloud-based crawler, and probably the best cloud based crawler out there. DeepCrawl can gather A LOT of data, but it becomes expensive. The … Incentivized Helpful? Ari Roth Senior Account Manager in Professional Services at Five Blocks Inc. (Public Relations and Communications, 11-50 employees) Chose Screaming Frog Moz's crawler is part of a larger, more expensive suite of proprietary tools. Screaming Frog is more affordable and does the job for those who don't need the other products offered by Moz. DeepCrawl makes some of the recommendations for you and is typically better for … Incentivized Helpful? Jane Phelps CEO at Know Agency (Marketing and Advertising, 11-50 employees) Chose Screaming Frog We actually use both other options, but screaming frog provides a great download of all pages in an easy format. It is more of a complimentary tool. Incentivized Helpful? Jeremy Waszak Senior SEO Manager in Marketing at Wpromote (Marketing and Advertising, 201-500 employees) Chose Screaming Frog Screaming Frog's combination of capabilities and pricing beats competitors. DeepCrawl & Moz beats out Screaming Frog when it comes to being able to access and store data since it is web-based and Screaming Frog data is stored locally. Otherwise, Screaming Frog is my go-to … Incentivized Helpful? Joseph Miller Senior SEO Manager in Marketing at Blucora (Financial Services, 501-1000 employees) Chose Screaming Frog DeepCrawl and Screaming Frog are complementary tools in my opinion. DeepCrawl is better for tracking progress over time while Screaming Frog is better for day to day adhoc requests. I use and recommend both. Both are more robust than the solutions offered by all in one … Incentivized Helpful? Sungwan Jo SEO Analyst in Marketing at 360i (Marketing and Advertising, 501-1000 employees) Chose Screaming Frog We have accounts for both. We use DeepCrawl to hum in the background to check for tech issues over time. Screaming Frog is used more on a regular basis. I use Screaming Frog more but I understand the benefits that each has. Incentivized Helpful?
	Would buy again
	No answers on this topic	No answers on this topic
	Delivers good value for the price
	No answers on this topic	No answers on this topic
	Happy with the feature set
	No answers on this topic	No answers on this topic
	Lived up to sales and marketing promises
	No answers on this topic	No answers on this topic
	Implementation went as expected
No answers on this topic	No answers on this topic

Features

Lumar

Screaming Frog

Comparison of SEO features of Lumar and Screaming Frog SEO Spider
Feature	Lumar 6.5 7 Ratings	Screaming Frog SEO Spider 8.7 52 Ratings
Keyword analysis	3.05 Ratings	7.419 Ratings
Backlink management	2.05 Ratings	6.022 Ratings
SERP ranking tracking	8.04 Ratings	8.08 Ratings
Page grader	10.04 Ratings	10.021 Ratings
Competitive analysis	5.04 Ratings	10.026 Ratings
Site audit / diagnostics	10.07 Ratings	10.052 Ratings
Site recommendations	10.06 Ratings	10.023 Ratings
Task management	4.04 Ratings	8.08 Ratings

Comparison of SEO Channels features of Lumar and Screaming Frog SEO Spider
Feature	Lumar 5.8 4 Ratings	Screaming Frog SEO Spider 9.5 36 Ratings
Local SEO	6.02 Ratings	8.116 Ratings
Social SEO	3.02 Ratings	10.011 Ratings
Mobile SEO	4.03 Ratings	10.022 Ratings
Global SEO	10.03 Ratings	10.028 Ratings

Comparison of SEO Platform & Account Management features of Lumar and Screaming Frog SEO Spider
Feature	Lumar 9.0 7 Ratings	Screaming Frog SEO Spider 8.8 41 Ratings
Multi-domain support	9.05 Ratings	10.030 Ratings
Integration with web analytics tools	9.07 Ratings	7.534 Ratings

User Ratings
	Lumar	Screaming Frog
Likelihood to Recommend	8.0 (7 ratings)	10.0 (54 ratings)
Likelihood to Renew	- (0 ratings)	10.0 (3 ratings)
Usability	6.0 (1 ratings)	8.5 (4 ratings)
Support Rating	7.0 (1 ratings)	7.9 (18 ratings)
Implementation Rating	- (0 ratings)	7.0 (1 ratings)